Chicago personal injury lawyer | Coplan and Crane

How Do I Know If the Personal Injury Settlement Offer Is Fair?

September 11, 2025

If you have a personal injury settlement offer on the table, it’s important to understand what it covers before you agree to accept it. While settling can allow you to recover financial compensation without going to trial, you need to be sure the offer is fair. If it isn’t, it may not fully cover your accident-related losses, leaving you with financial and other consequences that could—and should—be avoided.

So, how do you know if a personal injury settlement offer is fair?

Evaluating a personal injury settlement offer starts with understanding how much you are entitled to recover. If you don’t know what your case is worth, you don’t have any way of knowing whether you should accept any settlement offers that may be on the table. 

Determining Whether a Personal Injury Settlement Offer is Fair 

Generally speaking, accident victims are entitled to compensation for their financial and non-financial losses under Illinois law. As a result, in order to determine what your personal injury case is worth (and how much you should be willing to accept in a personal injury settlement), you will need to answer the following three questions: 

How Much Has the Accident Cost You Already?

First, you need to know how much the accident has cost you already. The costs associated with accident-related injuries generally fall into three broad categories:

  • Medical Bills – If you have medical bills (paid or unpaid) as a result of the accident, these are costs that should be included in your settlement. 
  • Other Out-of-Pocket Costs – Your settlement should also include compensation for your prescription medications, medical supplies, medical transportation, and any other out-of-pocket costs you have incurred. 
  • Lost Income – If you have missed work as a result of the accident, you are entitled to compensation for your lost income as well. 

While adding up these costs will be relatively straightforward in most cases, it is important to ensure that you do not overlook any costs you are entitled to recover. If you do, you won’t be able to go back and ask for more once you accept a personal injury settlement. 

How Much Will the Accident Cost You in the Future?

You also need to know how much the accident will cost you in the months or years ahead. Under Illinois law, accident victims are entitled to compensation for their present and future losses. Recoverable future losses generally include:

  • Future Medical Treatment – If you will need surgery, therapy or any other form of medical treatment in the future, your personal injury settlement should include the funds you will need to cover your future medical expenses. 
  • Future Necessary Expenses – Likewise, if you will need to pay for prescriptions, medical supplies, medical transportation, in-home care, or anything else related to your medical needs going forward, these are additional costs that you can—and should—seek to recover. 
  • Lost Future Earning Capacity – Your personal injury settlement should also include just compensation for your lost future earning capacity. This is true whether your injuries will prevent you from working for months, years, or the rest of your life. 

Calculating the future costs of accident-related injuries is a much more complicated process. Additionally, in many cases, accident victims’ future costs will far exceed their cost to date. With this in mind, it is critically important to ensure that you know how much your accident will cost you in the future before you accept a personal injury settlement. 

How Much Do You Deserve for Your Non-Financial Losses (Present and Future)?

Along with present and future financial costs, Illinois law entitles accident victims to compensation for their present and future non-financial losses as well. Common non-financial losses include:

  • Pain, suffering, and emotional trauma
  • Post-traumatic stress
  • Permanent scarring 
  • Loss of consortium and companionship
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Loss of services and support

Unlike financial costs, you cannot simply “add up” your non-financial losses to determine what constitutes a fair settlement in your case. Instead, determining how much you deserve to recover for these losses will involve working closely with your lawyer to critically assess all of the ways your injuries have impacted (and will continue to impact) your life. 

Speak with a Chicago Personal Injury Lawyer for FREE

If you have been seriously injured in an accident, we strongly encourage you to contact us before you accept a personal injury settlement. 

At Coplan + Crane, we’ve built our reputation on thorough case preparation, exceptional communication, and a commitment to securing the best possible results for our clients. We take the time to understand your situation, evaluate the details of your claim, and negotiate from a position of strength.

Contact the Chicago personal injury lawyers at Coplan + Crane today online or at (312) 982-0588 for a FREE case evaluation. We help clients across Illinois, including Chicago, Oak Park, Rockford, and other areas. We handle premises liability cases on a contingency basis, which means you don’t pay unless we win.